Subject: Re: Comment RR43 `the same as' needs to be better defined
eds#aber.ac.uk
Date: Mon May 29 2006 - 10:16:26 GMT
> Edel Mary Sherratt at eds#aber.ac.uk wrote on 27/4/06 10:16:
>> 7.2.2
>> ...
>> Comment RR43 `the same as' needs to be better defined
>>
>> I think this refers to the third paragraph of the Description subsection
>> of 15.3.12 StateMachine in the UML SS: `... the parameters of the state
>> machine
>> in this case match ... and provide the means for accessing ...
>> behavioral
>> feature parameters'
>>
>> Maybe we should just refer to UML SS here.
>
> I do not think that actually helps.
>
> The section cited above is a description and these sections seem to be
> non-normative to me. Even it is is normative it just replaces "same as" by
> "match", and I am not sure that is well defined. Maybe it is - but at the
> moment I have some doubts.
I agree that the whole issue of how parameters are handled is thorny.
Z.109 needs to be at least as clear as the UML SS. If we want to make
it more precise than the UML document (and I think we do), then we need
to state that - and I guess this means coming up with something formal
about parameter binding.
Edel
>
> --
> Rick Reed - rickreed#tseng.co.uk
> Tel:+44 15394 88462 Mob.:+44 7970 50 96 50
> Skype: rickreed_windermere
>
>
>
This archive was generated by hypermail 2a23 : Mon May 05 2008 - 20:30:55 GMT